fact-checking

SF election 2008 proposition fliers decoded

San Francisco election fliers 2008

View a sampling of dozens of fliers distributed in San Francisco to sway voters for and against propositions at our Flickr site -- and mouse over the graphics to read our reporters' commentary.

Prop D: Consensus on Pier 70?

By Bernice Yeung, Newsdesk.org/The Public Press

Although development is a perennially hot-button topic in San Francisco due to concerns about gentrification, Proposition D, which would facilitate Pier 70 revitalization, is a seemingly controversy-free measure that has garnered wide support from neighborhood groups, environmentalists, city officials and developers.

JROTC and Proposition V: Lessons in How Not to Listen

By Tim Kingston, Newsdesk.org/The Public Press

Sidebar: "Moderate vs. Progressive?"

For a measure that is completely nonbinding there is much sturm und drang around the "Policy Against Terminating Junior Reserve Officers' Training Corps (JROTC) in Public High Schools."

Debate is a limited commodity in the case of Proposition V; instead the two sides talk past and through each other -- loudly and heatedly. They also make claims that cannot be verified.

Prop. A: The Specter of a City Without a Lifeline

By Matthew Hirsch, Newsdesk.org/The Public Press

 
  View our annotated Flickr collection to see how pro-Propositon A activists are spinning the issue in campaign fliers.

The proponents of Proposition A want voters to believe that the Nov. 4 election is a matter of life or death for San Francisco's main public hospital.

The measure has an enormous list of supporters, including elected officials, newspapers, community groups, and the local Democratic, Republican and Green parties. The campaign ads also feature long endorsement lists and descriptions of health care specialists who provide essential medical services.

However, these ads misrepresent some of the facts. And they appeal to the lowest common denominator in politics -- quality health care, something everybody supports -- without taking on more difficult questions raised by the campaign.

Prop. M: The Latest Battle in San Francisco's Rent Wars

By Tim Kingston, Newsdesk.org/The Public Press

 
  View our annotated Flickr collection to see how pro- Proposition M activists are spinning the issue in campaign fliers.

Rancorous is always a good way to describe tenant-landlord relations in San Francisco, and the debate over Proposition M -- an anti-harassment initiative put on the ballot by tenants' rights activists -- is no exception.

The inelegantly dubbed Changing the Residential Rent Ordinance to Prohibit Specific Acts of Harassment of Tenants by Landlords attempts to do just that -- at great length, and has spurred an exchange of pro and con arguments around free speech and the role of lawyers.

Prop L: Political Maneuvering on Community Justice Center

By Bernice Yeung, Newsdesk.org/The Public Press

Proposition L, which would guarantee funding to San Francisco's new Community Justice Center, is supposedly an initiative that would "stop efforts to play politics with community justice," according to advertising paid for by proponents.

However, given the heated debate among city officials -- rooted in a longstanding feud between Supervisor Chris Daly and Mayor Gavin Newsom -- that surrounds the creation of the court, the measure appears to serve a political purpose itself.

Proposition B: 'Chump Change' or 'Massive Budget Hole'?

By Tim Kingston, Newsdesk.org/The Public Press

Sidebar: A Lopsided Playing Field

  Proposition B flier.
  See how pro-Proposition B activists are spinning the issue in campaign fliers.

The battle over public power and the hospital bond have vacuumed up much of San Francisco's attention and political capital this season.

But there's an equally significant, if under-the-radar, item up for grabs: Proposition B.

The "Establishing [an] Affordable Housing Fund" measure mandates that 2.5 cents out of every $100 in property taxes go to create what is essentially a dedicated San Francisco affordable housing account.

Proponents and opponents alike agree that it would raise roughly $2.7 billion over its 15-year lifespan -- in fact, that's about all they agree on.

Brass Tax: Propositions N and Q Levy Businesses, Property

  Proposition K flier.
  See how pro-Proposition N&Q activists are spinning the issue in campaign fliers.

By Tim Kingston, Newsdesk.org/The Public Press

Propositions N and Q, which would increase and modify San Francisco's property transfer and payroll expense taxes, were the product of intense negotiations between different business groups.

Not surprisingly, the winners and losers in those negotiations define the pro and con election advertisements.

The laws are simple enough: N would increase the property transfer tax from 0.75 to 1.5 percent on properties worth over $5 million, while Q ensures that partners in law firms have to pay payroll taxes. It also raises the ceiling for payroll tax exemption to $250,000.

The city controller states in the voter handbook that the propositions would raise almost $40 million for the city's general fund, but how it does that, and who stands to gain or lose, is not so clearcut.

Prop. K: Untested Theories Drive Prostitution Debate

  Proposition K flier.
  See how pro-Proposition K activists are spinning the issue in campaign fliers.

By Bernice Yeung, Newsdesk.org/The Public Press

Proposition K, which seeks to decriminalize prostitution in San Francisco, has spawned a heated debate over how to curb human trafficking and protect the lives and health of sex workers.

A close look at campaign advertising around the proposition reveals sharp disagreements between supporters and opponents over what the local impacts of the law would be, as well as a schism in feminist circles over prostitution itself.

The Business of Ballot Booklet Brokering

Campaigner and ex-City Hall aide David Noyola in an insider with election impact

By Matthew Hirsch, Newsdesk.org/The Public Press

Sidebar: Well connected

Like many who work in San Francisco City Hall, David Noyola last month was answering two phones, a land line for his official duties, and an iPhone to talk politics.

Noyola has since left his position as a legislative aide for Board of Supervisors President Aaron Peskin, and for election 2008 has put his specialized knowledge to use as a professional campaigner.

His work in these two capacities illustrates how insiders can have sizable impacts on local elections. In Noyola's case, his influence is currently most visible in the city's voter information guide -- the thick booklet published before each election that lists all the candidates and initiatives, as well as the official and paid arguments in support or opposition.

Syndicate content